|
J FROM: RE&INA M BOYLE FAX NO. * 209 5248911 ' 96-01-ss 12p,�y
<br /> F .1
<br /> 818P-Supp-292
<br /> 36 FRC 1612,23 E.nvd,L.R�PJ 1,255
<br /> (Ciao■s:S 18 F.Supp.292)
<br /> NQrr■id L.iTLVESTAD,As Tntstw for
<br /> the When decisionrtmw on applicable state law and states
<br /> Nervald 1-Ulvmtad Trust,Plakniff, hig st icourt liar trot adjudicated istare, diSown court
<br /> V. must make reasouabie &1mTninafiow4 based %q=
<br /> CHEVRON U.S.A.,INC_,a corporation; and mop=d soturcaes such as stamt es cad ptiblishsd
<br /> DOES 2 tlrew8h 100 loclusive, opittionrssul
<br /> , as to'�ret covet would rcach if faced with
<br /> DdL-adants. the istuie
<br /> 3 HEALTH AND KNYIRUNIMENTc P
<br /> Nb-3A,G'V 41-396-GLT. [ �
<br /> United States District Court. 199k25.5(3-I)
<br /> C.D- CaWOMia- Califartnia's Carpenter-Prealq-Tanner Hazardous
<br /> Substance Account Act specifically rr.quirrs fractions
<br /> April 6, 1993. of petro emw, iot Components of fractiqu to he listed
<br /> a9 hazardous s tbstacuctes in order to be sul4ect to Act;
<br /> Property uwner sued formar lessor of pmpcM. an oil thus,fait that t tat vls that leaked ftan gasoline:WKS
<br /> Contpany, to reoovcs costs of clummg up gwoiine were alleged :oto be refined petrol along with
<br /> tolu�m cad lme did not
<br /> which]tad leslced gas tanks oral had cantaminatcd F xY PrwJ°& �
<br /> sail and Wound water. Oil eorVany moved to dismiss Who
<br /> of:�tlee petroleum eacaltssaiml is the Act. j
<br /> cause of acbm for r vwm casts and dwlaratmy relief Wear's Arno-Ca1.Health & Sefcty Coote $g 25316,
<br /> under California's Carpenter- Presley'Caner 25317.
<br /> Harardous substance Account Acct on ground that F
<br /> refitted petroleum was excluded fru= rewh of Aq. 141 HEALTH AND ENVIROiV► VW9=
<br /> {
<br /> The .District Court, Tailor, J., Held that p0rvlcemr 25.5(3.il)
<br /> exclusion provision of Califomies ling 199k255(3.1)
<br /> Substeece Account Act excluded moation of rc6=A Ptirp:ase of wrdergrmo tank Program was to rczgattd
<br /> peM,1CUAI,includingto slaaorstitis of California's Hazardous Substaucc
<br /> Aaaotutt Act sild its inspplkabi*to refined petrttleetan
<br /> Motion gmaied, spills. !$ WeWs Ann.Cal-Health 8s Safety Code H
<br /> 25299,11 25299.10, 25310, 25385.6; Solid Waste
<br /> 11� WALTH AND ENV7R0NM]fNTQ' Disposid Ac:t,;P$ 9()01 ct seq.-, 9W3(h), as amawkd,
<br /> 23.5£3`1)
<br /> 42 U&C.A. §§6991 et seg.,6991b(h).
<br /> 199k25.5(3.1) &293 saa
<br /> Gib ,Oum &. Cruta-.her, Joel S. Ma$mwitz,
<br /> Refined p�roleum products snob as gasoline ate Jty, T3- Diittzsr, Los Angeles, CAF for plaintiff
<br /> excluded f m reach of Califwniids CsrprtntW-Freaky- Nmvdd L. Ul%wtad as Tnistee for Nuivald L.
<br /> Tonne* 1lt�ardotls Subo=e Aecct a ,Act. Act Ulvestid'F`ItiSt.
<br /> excludes Som definitm of bazw&= strbstamces
<br /> petro scum, including engie oil or any iiuetian themf LiaAmI mon, Mchwt A- Taue:lznaiN Alschider,
<br /> which is not otherwise specifically listed or desiSm d Grosse=� Pitres, Loa Angeles, CA, fes detendatit
<br /> a9 hazardous mbsta:ece. West's Ann-Cal.Health & Cbcvro tU.S.A.lac.
<br /> Safety Gods§§25300-25395,25317,25363(e). Chief' Casrsd, Jcttrtl ,al
<br /> �I
<br /> ]awes;FL CI#GgK B
<br /> 121 FEDERAL COURTS dt=390 Ma tea Staff Atty., CaYornik Fnvir R=tal
<br /> 170Bk39 0 Rate .1 on Agency Dept• of Toxic Substan=Corttml,
<br /> When mm turns cat applicable state lave and state's $aCregttealto, CA, for Stats of Cal.. Dept- Of Tcxic
<br /> lugbm c*uri has not ad�catred issue, district court 6tirbe t saes Control,for mancros curiae.
<br /> must make mmoaaWe tiztatiomb based WM
<br /> recognized � do Suss statutes cad gdbiisivad
<br /> OkDER GRAl TING MOT10N TO DISMSS
<br /> opinions, as to result court would reach if l-atred with THIRD AND FOURTH CAUSIRS OF ACTION
<br /> the is�te-
<br /> TAYLOR,District Judge.
<br /> 121 FEDERAL COURTS d=393
<br /> L 70$k391 This case mists doe ice,cert apparw fin'st mvre-mim
<br /> Ceapr,0 West 1998 No Claim to Orig.U.S.Govt Warks
<br /> jr
<br /> f �
<br /> Iq
<br />
|