WORK PLANS - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

DRAFT January 4, 2012 micromohs per centimeter(Nmhos/cm). This value, at a minimum, exceeds the applicable, upper range, numeric EC objective in the Basin Plan. The Basin Plan incorporates by reference specific tables from Title 22 as numeric water quality objectives for groundwater designated for municipal use.39 The tables include Table 64449-B, which contains secondary maximum contaminant levels for EC. They consist of a range of values— recommended, upper, and short-term values. These values are 900, 1,600, and 2,200 Nmhos/cm, respectively. Evidence in the record indicates that the median EC concentration in groundwater underlying the facility near the storage ponds from 2001 to 2005 exceeded the upper range value of 1,600 Nmhos/cm. The short-term value of 2,200 Nmhos/cm is not appropriate because it is intended to apply only on a temporary basis pending construction of water treatment facilities or the development of new water sources. The Basin Plan incorporates as groundwater objectives only the numeric values in the selected tables from Title 22.40 It does not incorporate other provisions of Title 22, such as the provisions on monitoring, reporting, or waivers.41 The Basin Plan does not require that the Central Valley Water Board establish a fixed consumer acceptance contaminant level prior to implementing the groundwater EC objective. No additional data is necessary to conclude that, at a minimum, groundwater underlying the White Slough facility exceeds the upper range of the secondary maximum contaminant level for EC. Likewise, the average EC value exceeds the agricultural water quality goal of 700 Nmhos/cm as a long-term average, which, according to the Lodi permit, "would apply the narrative chemical constituents objective".42 This goal "is intended to prevent reduction in crop yield . . . for salt-sensitive crops, such as beans, carrots, turnips, and strawberries," which "are either currently grown in the area or may be grown in the future.,,43 Nevertheless, the Board notes that site-specific factors, such as periodic flooding or rainfall patterns, can affect irrigation 39 Basin Plan at III-10.00. 41 Ibid. The Basin Plan states that ground waters designated for municipal use"shall not contain concentrations of . chemical constitutents in excess of the . . . [MCLs] specified in the following provisions of Title 22. . ., which are incorporated by reference into this plan: Tables 64449-A. . . and 64449-B.° (Emphasis added.) 41 Accord, State Water Board Order WQ 2003-0009 (County Sanitation District No. 2 of Los Angeles and Bill Robinson). 42 Order No. R5-2007-0113, F-36. 43 Id. at F-36 through F-37. 15.