Laserfiche WebLink
Table 9: Comparative Analysis of Selected Alternatives Geosyntec Consultants <br /> Rough and Ready Island,Site 47 <br /> Port of Stockton <br /> ° Q" <br /> Alternatives ., eq �., �°� U o v, �o kn O 0 0 <br /> o y W w W <br /> FF .0 F a�i = F '' ° U F = .� F o o <br /> Evaluation F z F U F 3 a o a o Q <br /> Criteria o , <br /> x ° o <br /> U U <br /> W W W V <br /> � k � <br /> Overall Protection of Human No No Yes Yes Yes <br /> Health and the Environment <br /> Compliance with Applicable or <br /> Relevant and Appropriate No Yes Yes Yes Yes <br /> Requirements(ARARs) <br /> Long-Term Effectiveness and Ranked 5th Ranked 4th Ranked 1st Ranked 1st Ranked 1st <br /> Permanence <br /> Short-Term Effectiveness Ranked 5th Ranked 4th Ranked 1st(tied) Ranked 3rd Ranked 1st(tied) <br /> Reduction of Toxicity,Mobility, Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable <br /> and Volume through Treatment <br /> Implementability Ranked 1 st Ranked 2nd Ranked 3rd(tied) Ranked 3rd(tied) Ranked 3rd(tied) <br /> Cost Ranked 1st Ranked 2nd Ranked 3rd(tied) Ranked 5th Ranked 3rd(tied) <br /> Overall Ranking Ranked 5th Ranked 4th Ranked 1st(tied) Ranked 3rd Ranked Ist(tied) <br /> Notes <br /> 1.Alternatives are ranked from most favorable(1st)to least favorable(5th). <br /> 2.Alternatives 1 and 2 are ranked last because they do not meet one or more of the threshold criteria(i.e.,Overall Protection <br /> of Human Health and the Environment and Compliance with ARARs). <br /> Page 1 of 1 <br />